Baseball

“I wrote 63 songs this year. They’re all about Jeter.” Just kidding. The game we love, the players we hate, and more.

Culture and Criticism

From Norman Mailer to Wendy Pepper — everything on film, TV, books, music, and snacks (shut up, raisins), plus the Girls’ Bike Club.

Donors Choose and Contests

Helping public schools, winning prizes, sending a crazy lady in a tomato costume out in public.

Stories, True and Otherwise

Monologues, travelogues, fiction, and fart humor. And hens. Don’t forget the hens.

The Vine

The Tomato Nation advice column addresses your questions on etiquette, grammar, romance, and pet misbehavior. Ask The Readers about books or fashion today!

Home » The Vine

The Vine: January 24, 2002

Submitted by on January 24, 2002 – 6:02 PMNo Comment

Sarah,

I would love your objective opinion on a problem I’m having with my mother-in-law. She is a 70-year-old chain-smoking alcoholic with various health problems. According to her, she is always on the brink of death. She recently retired from her part-time job, and seems to have started full-time drinking as a replacement. Here is where my problem comes in.

She is always nagging at my husband about how lonely she is and how we never spend any time with her, even though “she probably won’t be around much longer.” She claims that is why she drinks. I say that she is lonely because she drinks since she is a mean drunk and very unpleasant to be around. She loves to lay the guilt trip on him about how she knows we are always too busy with our friends to spend any time with her. My husband, who is a nice guy, is deeply affected by her guilt trips and therefore puts up with way too much of her crap. The truth is that we don’t want to spend our precious free time with someone who is so miserable to be around. I know that deep down she loves me and is glad I am married to her son, but when she is drinking she acts like a jealous ex-girlfriend, making comments about how “fat” I was while I was pregnant, et cetera. In short, she is really rude.

Also, we have a one-year-old daughter, who is her only grandchild and her “reason for living.” Well, last time she invited us over for dinner, she was already drunk when we got there, and announced that she was too drunk to play with the baby (not to mention she is chain-smoking the whole time). So there was a wasted Saturday with no credit for spending time with her.

Her latest stunt involves my father-in-law, who she has been divorced from for 25 years. He has been ill and has had several heart operations in the recent past. She likes to call us and leave sobbing messages on our answering machine about how he is dying and she is going to fly down to his house and take care of him. We have been through this many times before. Last night she sank to a new low by leaving a message saying that he had died and begging my husband to answer the phone (he doesn’t answer when he knows she has been drinking). Naturally this scared both of us, and after a call to my father-in-law verifying that he was in fact still alive, I told my husband that she had gone too far. She basically ruined our Sunday evening. One of these days if something really did happen, we would probably ignore it, thinking she was crying wolf again.

I know that alcoholism is a disease, but I believe she is still accountable for her actions even if she doesn’t remember them, because we sure do. I have dealt with her by ignoring her drunken stunts in the past, but it is getting to the point where we can’t even answer the phone. Not to mention I really don’t want my baby subjected to a wasted grandma. When she is sober, she can be nice, although she has a pretty irritating personality. She is a very negative person and doesn’t have anything good to say about anyone or anything. I put a lot of effort into keeping my mouth shut when she is around, just because I love my husband and I know her behavior is very embarrassing for him. Basically I wish she would just go away, but since that is not going to happen, I would love to hear any advice or suggestions you may have on how to deal. Thanks so much!

Screening All Calls

Dear Screening,

Your mother-in-law does these things because they work. If she didn’t have success with that strategy, she wouldn’t bother.

I would tell you to cut her off completely, but your husband probably won’t go for that, so set limits for what you will tolerate, and stick to them. Your husband can do as he pleases, but you won’t play the game with his mother anymore. You won’t field the weepy phone calls; you won’t get sucked into the woe-is-me routine and the use of your father-in-law as an emotional bargaining chip; you won’t go on the guilt trips. If you go to visit her and she’s drunk, you will gather up your daughter and leave right then. This isn’t an indictment of your husband, and you should make that clear — but you should also make it clear that, if he won’t set boundaries for you as a family, you will set them for yourself.

You and your husband have taught your mother-in-law that her actions have no consequences, but you don’t have to punish her; you just have to stop letting her punish you. So, stop.

You seem like the kind of gal I’d be happy to throw back a couple beers with. I need to know what you’d do in the following situation.

I’m friends with a medium-sized group of people who all pretty much hang out every time we can. We all get along marvelously as a group and fabulously one-on-one. I like every single one of them for different reasons, and really love hanging out with them as often as we can manage it. Here’s the problem.

One of us is dating the most annoying she-beast from hell who all of us, independently of one another, have come to dislike. Some of us hate her, some of us find her mildly irritating, but all of us don’t really like it when she’s around. Even the one who’s dating her seems to find her annoying most of the time, but won’t (or can’t or doesn’t) break up with her for whatever reason. At first we all just sort of dealt with her, because we knew we had to and because she seemed harmless enough. Several months have passed since then, and this girl has managed to piss us all off individually at different points by saying or doing something directly to us that we found offensive. And we’re REALLY not the kind of people who offend easily. He spends 40 hours a week working with her and basically lives with her, even though nothing’s official and he keeps insisting they’re not that serious. I think he doesn’t break up with her because it’s not like he can tell her to shove off and then never see her again; she sits right next to him all day every day at work.

We all adore him (even if he’s clearly got issues) and love hanging out with him, so cutting him off or not calling him if we’re getting together would be out of the question. At the same time, I don’t know how much longer I, or any of us, can keep going the way we’ve been going. As it stands now, we all get together; she shows up and says or does something really stupid or mean, and either gets walked away from, made fun of, or yelled at, depending on what she’s done and who she’s talking to. This causes her to storm off until he goes to make nice, and causes him to have to either apologize on her behalf or get pissed at us for being mean to her. Normally I’d wash my hands of the whole thing and just avoid her like the plague, but to avoid her means to also avoid him, and in some cases to avoid all my friends altogether. I don’t want to do that, and I’m tired of her constantly ruining our good time. What should I do?

Tiptoeing around the elephant in the living room

Dear Tiptoeing,

You have two choices. You can tolerate She-Beast as best you can, or you can stop spending time with Mr. She-Beast until/unless they break up.

What’s that? You don’t like either of those options? Well…too bad. There’s no magic bullet here. You can’t push the girl under a train. You can’t force your friend to dump her. You have to decide how important it is to you to continue hanging out with Mr. She-Beast, and you have to live with the decision one way or the other.

But before you decide, sit back, put your feet up, and join me in a steaming mug of Pop-Psych Zinger, because the thing is, She-Beast knows that you all hate her. She may not acknowledge it in so many words, but you may rest assured that she knows, and that she and Mr. She-Beast have discussed (read: fought about) it many times. She acts out the way she does, in part, because you expect her to; you dislike her, so she’s decided to prove you right. She also does it to mark her territory, to circle Mr. She-Beast off from the herd, to force him over and over again to choose between her and the group. Secretly, she hopes that you all will give up on him so that she can have him all to herself. In other words, she’s deeply insecure and fucked up. Cookie?

Okay, here’s what you do. Suck it up and keep socializing with your friend, and if She-Beast acts up, just laugh it off. She’s a beeyatch, but it has nothing to do with you, so you shouldn’t take it personally. Maybe Mr. She-Beast will come to his senses one day and evict her from your lives; maybe you’ll just stop giving a shit about her personality disorder. Either way, you win.

Share!
Pin Share


Tags:    

Leave a comment!

Please familiarize yourself with the Tomato Nation commenting policy before posting.
It is in the FAQ. Thanks, friend.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>