Baseball

“I wrote 63 songs this year. They’re all about Jeter.” Just kidding. The game we love, the players we hate, and more.

Culture and Criticism

From Norman Mailer to Wendy Pepper — everything on film, TV, books, music, and snacks (shut up, raisins), plus the Girls’ Bike Club.

Donors Choose and Contests

Helping public schools, winning prizes, sending a crazy lady in a tomato costume out in public.

Stories, True and Otherwise

Monologues, travelogues, fiction, and fart humor. And hens. Don’t forget the hens.

The Vine

The Tomato Nation advice column addresses your questions on etiquette, grammar, romance, and pet misbehavior. Ask The Readers about books or fashion today!

Home » The Vine

The Vine: May 16, 2002

Submitted by on May 16, 2002 – 11:41 PMNo Comment

Dear Sars,

Anyway.So here’s the deal.I’m 26, well-educated, relatively normal on most accounts.I don’t have a boyfriend, nor have I ever (I’ve been overweight all of my life).Now, I’m not one of those I’m-all-about-marriage chicks, but from time to time I think about how cool it would be to have some dude I dig be psyched enough about me to at least say some sort of vow about forever and blahbety blah blah.The older I get, the less I see that happening anywhere but in my mind.Problem is, I dig kids in a big way, so I definitely want one or some at some point.

I’ve thought a lot about this, and I don’t want to go the sperm bank route because, well…ew.I’ve thought about the qualities of the genes I would want to mesh with mine, and I always reach the same conclusion: if I could hand-pick one person with whom to procreate, it would be one of my best friends — I’ll call him “Joe.”

Joe and I are very close friends, but, to the best of my knowledge, it has never, ever been anything romantic whatsoever, on either of our parts.It’s not about getting to sleep with him (that may not even be the way it gets done); it’s about getting his genes. We have what I guess I’d call a very close spiritual and intellectual connection.He’s definitely the smartest person I know, and intellect is pretty much the most important thing to me in a mate (albeit followed closely by sense of humor and compassion). We’ve actually discussed the idea of him impregnating me, and he has basically agreed to it — in fact, he brings it up on occasion.

Here’s where the real problem lies: Joe is married and has two kids of his own.His whole marriage scene is a big debacle to begin with, but people make their own choices, you know?I would never, ever want to interfere with his marriage or the life he’s built for himself, but he is always the first in my mind when I think of whose children I’d really like to bear.

So the problem isn’t really a case of feelings I have for him, or he for me, or anything like that.The problem is, I guess, is this doable?I mean, the fact that it’s really likely his wife would freak if she knew we were even talking about this sucks, but in actuality, they live in a totally different state, and not to be a total spawn of Satan but she’d never really have to know if we didn’t want her to.

But what would I tell the kid?”Yeah, your dad is married to another woman somewhere else and has kids of his own — well, yeah, your stepbrother is a few years older than you, but who’s counting?”And to make matters worse, my best friend (the three of us went to college together) desperately fell in love with Joe right before we graduated, spilled it to him, and is now banned from ever talking to him, courtesy of the wifey.If my best friend found out that he and I were talking about this, it’d be another issue altogether.

What do I do?I don’t want to be selfish and risk freaking his wife (and admittedly a few others, most likely) out, but if he and I are both in favor of it, is it still wrong?In my opinion, it’s worth the risk, but I’d like an outsider’s perspective.I hope I don’t sound like a total psychotic bitch to all of those happily married women out there.I swear I’m not trying to be a homewrecker, not in the least. It’s not about that.

Thanks in advance for any advice you can give, as the clock is ticking as we speak.

Straight Single-Mom Wannabe

Dear Wannabe,

All right, first of all?You’re 26, not 46.The clock isn’t ticking that loudly.You have oodles of biological time before you have to make a decision about this, and you’d better use every minute, because it’s not just your life that it’s going to affect.It’s Joe’s life, and his wife’s, and their kids’, and your best friend’s, and your potential child’s.Sloooooowwww it down.If you go ahead with this, you can’t go back from it.

I can’t point to exactly why, but I get the sense that you don’t have a realistic view of how this is going to play out.This isn’t a matter of taking the hand-off of Joe’s sperm and going on your merry way.For starters, there are legalities involved here that I don’t think you’ve considered in a serious way.Do you have a full understanding of what Joe’s paternal responsibilities would be under the law?Would you ask him to sign them away, or would you want him to be involved and available at all to you and your child?You say you don’t, but what if the baby turns up with a rare genetic disorder that’s not traceable to you, and you need a full medical history from Joe — what then?

You’ll have to retain a lawyer, you’ll have to make sure Joe retains a lawyer, and that’s going to make it impossible to hide from Mrs. Joe.And Mrs. Joe might drop the hammer on it, from the sounds of it.Have you thought about what happens if you go ahead with it and it doesn’t work out?Mrs. Joe nixes the plan?You don’t get pregnant?You don’t carry the baby to term?What then?You’re back at square one, except that Mrs. Joe probably cuts you off.Ditto your best friend.

And if you do have the child…I certainly don’t subscribe to the theory that a child “needs” a father figure by any means, but what if Joe Jr. wants to find Joe and his half-siblings in fifteen or twenty years’ time?What, he’s going to go on Unsolved Mysteries with a photo of Joe and hope one of his half-siblings calls the hotline?

Again, this isn’t a matter of get the sperm, have the baby, fade to black.This situation is going to exist for the rest of your natural life.Even if she does allow Joe to donate sperm for you, Mrs. Joe is probably going to insist that that’s the end of his contact with you.You’ll have a job of work explaining where the baby came from to your best friend.You’ll get your baby, but you’ve given up on relationships, apparently, so you’ll have to raise Joe Jr. on your own, which is a perfectly valid choice but certainly not an easy one.

I can’t tell you if all that is worth it to you; maybe it is, maybe it isn’t, and if you really want Joe’s child and nobody else’s, well, I guess you’ve got your work cut out for you.My advice?Before you do anything, meet with an attorney who specializes in reproductive law, and talk seriously and honestly to him or her about the situation before you make any decisions.You’re still so young; so much could still happen to change your point of view.The situation is extremely complicated.Proceed with caution.

Readers: I don’t know fuck-all about the law here.If anyone has a similar situation or advice they’d like to share, please email me.

Sars,

Help!My roommate is a moron.

I’ve been living in this particular dorm room for two years.I’ve had several roommates and have never had any problems before.But this roommate is ridiculous.It’s her last semester and she is doing her student internship.She gets up an hour and half before I do and insists on turning on the television.I tried being polite about it…gritting my teeth and bearing it, mostly.Then I couldn’t take it anymore, and I finally asked her if she would mind turning it off…that I couldn’t sleep with it on.She refused.I even tried compromising, asking her to restrict herself to twenty minutes and then cutting it off.But no, she couldn’t do that either.

She eventually brought her own TV to the room, using the excuse that she didn’t want to use anyone else’s belongings.I even had to move my VCR and DVD player in order for her to have space for her TV.I also had to buy a stand for my TV.This is crazy.I like watching it as much as the next person, but she watches it every minute she is in the room.I’ve lost all respect for her due to her complete lack of consideration for me.

She also has this thing with the heat.I can’t breathe real well if I get too hot, but she insists that she has to have the heat on in order to avoid getting sick.Again, she doesn’t even take me into consideration.It’s like I don’t even live here or something.I’m trying very hard to ignore her.I feel like I am nitpicking because we got off to a bad start.Plus, I’m feeling very petty and vindictive.I’ve started doing little things like leaving my radio on loud, turning the heat off after she has just turned it on, and leaving the light on well after she has gone to bed.

Any advice you have would be great.I doubt I can get rid of her, though I have thought of some rather evil plots.Ideally I would like to be able to sit in my room…ignore her…and stay calm and relaxed rather than pissed off and tense.

Enraged Roommate

Dear Enraged,

Try talking to her one more time.Tell her you know the two of you got off to a bad start, but some of her behavior is making the situation unliveable for you.Tell her you really need her to cut down on the TV watching and to turn the heat down now and then; you know she’d rather not, but you’d like to work out some sort of compromise that’s agreeable to both of you.

If she point-blank refuses, you’re done.She’s rude and selfish and she won’t hear reason.Go to the housing office and get one of you transferred to another room.If they won’t transfer you, file a complaint stating that you want part of your housing fee refunded because living with that beast interfered with your ability to do your schoolwork, and make sure the dean of student life gets a copy.

Then write an epic poem in iambic pentameter about how much she sucks.Call it “O, How Hot And Fuckin’ Loud ‘Tis In My Domicile.”Run off five hundred copies at Kinko’s and post them all over campus.Then kill her.

Just kidding about the killing-her part.Seriously, just talk to her, and if that doesn’t work, get up housing’s ass to find you another place to live.You pay to go there; get your money’s worth.

Share!
Pin Share


Tags:    

Comments are closed.