Baseball

“I wrote 63 songs this year. They’re all about Jeter.” Just kidding. The game we love, the players we hate, and more.

Culture and Criticism

From Norman Mailer to Wendy Pepper — everything on film, TV, books, music, and snacks (shut up, raisins), plus the Girls’ Bike Club.

Donors Choose and Contests

Helping public schools, winning prizes, sending a crazy lady in a tomato costume out in public.

Stories, True and Otherwise

Monologues, travelogues, fiction, and fart humor. And hens. Don’t forget the hens.

The Vine

The Tomato Nation advice column addresses your questions on etiquette, grammar, romance, and pet misbehavior. Ask The Readers about books or fashion today!

Home » The Vine

The Vine: May 24, 2005

Submitted by on May 24, 2005 – 2:33 PMNo Comment

This story is about seventeen and a third days long, but I shall condense it.

Teenager. First boyfriend. First sex. STD pops up. I’m horrified and feel like, basically, a dirty filthy whore (and I know that’s irrational). What now? How do I handle this? How do I tell future boyfriends?

Signed,
Goodbye Future Lusty Casual Sexual Relationships

[I tagged an expert in for this one; her response is below. — Sarah]

Dear Don’t Worry, They’re Still Possible,

First off, let me just give you a big, long virtual hug. I’ve got herpes, I’ve been there — I wasn’t a teenager, but it was the second guy I’d ever had sex with. On my birthday. The night he threatened to make a scene at my friend’s wedding reception. Talk about rubbing salt into the wound, so to speak…

Secondly, please, please try anything to get the whore thoughts out of your head. You’re the one who is your harshest critic at a time like this, which I know because I did the same thing. It happens to old, young, those with one partner and those with 100 partners — hindsight is 20/20. Mine is from unprotected sex, and if you knew the guy, you’d think I would have known better. STDs happen to anyone — in the case of herpes alone, 20-25% of the adult population has it, and the stats for STDs in general are even more astronomical. But that can make it worse, because then you wonder where all of these other mythical people are. I’m here, and I’ve found others. I promise.

The first thing to do is take care of you. Make sure you’ve visited the doctor and gotten the medication you need both for what you’ve contracted, and then anything that can help ease any pain straightaway. It might take a while to get it under control, but you’ll get there and then you can think more clearly. Also take care of yourself mentally — you might look into talking to a therapist who can help you as well. I know at least for herpes that there are also local support groups all over the country that you can find through your local public health office if you feel you need it. And feel free to rage and scream and get mad, because it sucks, and it’s unfair, and there’s no reason why it should have happened to you over someone else.

But after that, take heart. I’ve made the choice to tell potential partners about it, and I’ve had really good luck. It might be harder for you because you’re a teenager — I’m not going to assure you that anyone and everyone will be fine. But there are plenty of good people out there who will be okay, or who will let you educate them to learn that they’ll be okay. As you get older, you’ll probably find this more and more. The way that I started out was by telling my friends, and then gradually widening the circle. (In one memorable moment, drunk at a bar, I raised my fist in the air and screamed, “YAY HERPES!” to all of my friend’s co-workers, as she tried to escort me to the ladies’ room. For the record, I got back and one girl leaned over and said, “Oh, herpes? EVERYBODY’S got that.”) It’s not the same, but it shows you that people aren’t going to run and scream in fear.

The first time that you tell a sexual partner is going to be horrendously scary. It will get easier, though it will never get easy. And it’s ice-cold comfort to say that it’s a good litmus test for people in general — anyone who would freak out and be an asshole probably isn’t someone you want to be doing the horizontal mambo with anyway — but I guarantee that you’ll start to feel better about it with time. I don’t say that to scare you, but rather to assure you that those feelings are normal and anyone who has been through it knows. It’s not easy, but it’s something that you can absolutely get through. And the first time you are with someone who is okay with it will be one of the best experiences of your life, no matter how the sex actually turns out.

Good luck, and make your top priority feeling better. Then you’ll be so much better equipped to move forward.

Yours truly,
Mister Zero

Hi, Sars!

I’ve got a grammar conundrum. Garner mentions that “who” is the
relative pronoun for human beings, and “that”/”which” is the relative
pronoun for anything other than humans. Being a persnickety
oh-but-what-about-this-particular-case-that-no-one-cares-about kind of
person, I started wondering about things that are not human but might
take the “who” rather than the “that”/”which.”

Case 1: cognizant aliens. “To demonstrate the noblesse oblige of the
Vulcans, it needs to be Spock who dies in ‘Wrath of Khan.'” Or: “To
demonstrate the noblesse oblige of the Vulcans, it needs to be Spock that dies
in ‘Wrath of Khan.'”

Case 2: cognizant animals. “Flipper the dolphin, who was known for
rescuing people, died at the hands of poachers.” Or: “Flipper, the
dolphin that was known for rescuing people, died at the hands of
poachers.”

Case 3: legal entity or artificial person: “Many corporations who are
buying new businesses haven’t even tested their profitability.” Or:
“Many corporations that are buying new businesses haven’t even tested
their profitability.” (Adapted from Garner WHO;WHOM (D).)

The first seems straightforward enough: on their planet the aliens
themselves would use “who,” so we should too. The second seems to blur
the line, as we have no idea if dolphins have advanced enough language
for this problem to arise. The last seems to contradict Garner’s
example, if “companies” is replaced by “corporations” and corporations
are defined as humans as opposed to like humans.

I’d love to hear your trenchant interpretation of my dilemma.

Cheers,
Fastidiously Self-Flagellating

Dear Nnnnnnnerd!,

Hee. Just kidding.

I think you’re looking at this from the wrong angle here, actually. On their planet, presumably, the aliens use a different language entirely and aren’t subject to the rules of English — and in any case, what they would call themselves doesn’t necessarily govern them in terms of third-party usage. With that said, I think you use “who/whom” on humans, and aliens or animals or talking cars in which you’ve observed or to which you’ve assigned human-like qualities. For instance, you’d say, “The chair that I was just sitting in broke,” but you’d also say, “Chairy, who is a character on Pee-Wee’s Playhouse, is awesome,” because Chairy is in fact a “person” of sorts. So, in your first two examples, I’d use the first versions.

Companies and corporations are different, because, while they are composed of people, they do not operate in a human way (insert Halliburton joke here). Same goes for armies and, I’d imagine, crowds.

Garner’s right, in other words, but I think it’s okay to use “who/whom” on entities that, while not strictly human from a DNA standpoint, share human qualities or have been anthropomorphized. Any old Camaro, no; K.I.T.T., yes.

I have a wedding-related question.
What’s the etiquette when the bride has more people she wants as
bridesmaids than the groom has/wants as groomsmen? I’ve seen weddings
where one groomsman will walk down the aisle with a bridesmaid on each
arm or whatever, but here’s the real problem: I have a brother who I
think my fiance will have as one of his groomsmen, along with a couple
of his friends, but my fiance also has two sisters…one being a twin
(so they’re obviously very close). I’d like my brother to be a part of
our wedding, but does this mean that I have to include his two sisters
as my bridesmaids? (And yes, I know how selfish that sounds.)

I’m
already having problems choosing from my closest friends…I don’t
really have room for girls I’m NOT close to yet! They don’t live near
here, so while I’m sure we’ll spend some time together before the
wedding, we certainly won’t be bonding 24/7 or anything yet. But I
also don’t want to insult his family. Are there other roles special
enough to equate them with being part of the bridal party? Or should I
not even worry about this? One of his sisters (the non-twin) I’ve only
met twice, and one of those times was at her wedding, where I had no
role. We barely even spoke. I wasn’t engaged to her brother at that
time, though.

My fiance has spent plenty of time with my brother. Wedding party of
56, here we come!

Signed,
A peep in the 732

Dear The 908 Says Relax,

I…am totally confused right now with the whole brother/non-twin/do-si-do-your-sibling thing happening here, but! No problem, because I don’t need to know who’s related to whom and how close to give you some suggestions.

First of all, if you want to go with a traditional “women on the bride’s side, men on the groom’s” layout, that’s fine, and I’ll get to that strategy in a sec, but if you’re not married (as it were) to that set-up, you might consider just calling everyone “honor attendants,” picking whomever you want to go on whichever side s/he’s closer to, and leaving it at that. You’d still have to even up the numbers, I guess, on either side of the aisle, but if it’s primarily an issue of “I want my brother in the wedding and it throws the balance off,” just put him on your side.

But if you’d rather keep it split along gender lines, again, no prob — just sit down with your fiance and make up a list of people you want in the wedding. Not people you know he wants, or people you feel you “should” put in the wedding party, but the people you want. Have him do the same thing. Then compare lists and divvy everyone up by men and women, and see where you are…and if one side is totally lopsided, either by gender or by yours/his, start negotiating.

I would really try to keep the wedding party itself at five on a side or fewer, just because life is short and dress fittings suck, but if you’ve got more people than that that you really want to include, ask people to read poems or sing songs in the service.

You might have to “cut” people, though; it’s an unfortunate part of weddings that you’ve always got a few people who are hurt by not being as involved as they’d assumed they’d be.

Hi Sars,

I love both your writing and your advice, so I figured you were the best
person to ask a writing-related question.

I’ve written a novel. Of course, that’s not quite the same thing as
having written a Good Novel.

Here’s a little background. After writing the novel, I gave it to a few
people and asked for feedback. I got several very helpful comments, but
in general, I think the friends and family who read it were too kind. It
doesn’t help that it’s a romance novel, and I only have one friend who has
ever read romances (and she tries to keep it on the down low). To give you
an idea of how nice my friends are, even the two men that I had read it
said they really enjoyed it, which…please…while there is no actual
bodice-ripping, it is a romance novel with all that entails. It was at
that point that I realized I would get no serious criticism from people
who like me.

I’ve sent the book out to agents, and while I received a couple of
requests for full or partial manuscripts and one or two positive comments,
nobody was interested in trying to pitch it to publishers. So, I guess my
question is…what next? Is it worth it to pay somebody to edit the damn
thing? As much as it would suck to see it dripping with red ink, I feel
like that’s the only way it’s going to get better. I certainly can’t
count on my friends to do that. Besides their reluctance to tell me
anything I don’t want to hear, it’s also too much work to ask somebody to
do for nothing. I know that there are writing groups online, but I’m not
entirely sure how to go about finding one that will actually be helpful.
I’ve been in writing groups and classes, and they are often not very
critical. Also, I have a full-time job, so the idea of spending days
editing somebody else’s novel in exchange is less attractive than the idea
of writing a check.

What do you think? Do you know anybody who edits romance novels? Would
you have any idea what you would pay somebody to do this? Is this a
reasonable thing to do, or is it a rip-off?

Thanks for everything,
If I Can’t Come Up With a Catchy Signature, Does That Make Me a Bad Writer?

Dear Sig,

I’ll edit whatever I’m paid to edit, so feel free to email me for rates; I’m happy to have a look, and romance novels aren’t my area but I used to read them by the pound back in the day.

Failing that, no, I don’t know anyone who edits romance novels in particular, but it does sound like you need a fresh set of eyes on it…and I agree with you that workshops tend to be a bit too gentle when direct criticisms are what’s needed. So, maybe an online group is your best bet — people tend to be less varnished in their comments on the internet (…”she says, in the understatement of the year”), so you might get some good feedback from that.

Or just pay an editor to have a look at it. It doesn’t have to be me, but if you find someone by Googling whose eye you think you can trust, send it out and see what s/he has to say. At the very least you might get some new ideas or perspectives. And keep sending it out to agents; they’re the ones who will have to move it forward, so I’d keep looking on that front at the same time.

Sars,

Oh, giver of wisdom, please help me with this situation. It’s not even about boys, I swear. I hate my job. HATE!

I’ve been here for two years. I work my freaking tail off for a crazy, work-obsessed control freak of a boss who never lets up. For example, she is out of town today for a statewide meeting. At the time of this plea for help (3:45 PM), I have already received forty-five frantic emails from this woman regarding minute details that need to be attended to. HATRED. The reason I have stuck around so long is that I felt like I was essential to the “team.” Obviously not, if she feels the need to send me forty-five emails. Were it not for the fact that I’m leaving for graduate school at the start of August, I would quit today.

And therein lies the rub. I’ll be gone in two and a half months. I know I have to suck it up and keep plugging along, with my eye on July 29th. How do I keep myself from having a nervous breakdown before then?

Drowning in a Sea of Papers

Dear Drown,

After two years, maybe it’s time to stop taking things so personally. You know what this woman is, what she’s like; that boss personality type is not fun, but it’s the norm rather than the exception, in my experience, and if it’s in fact your job to attend to minute details…attend to them. I get hundreds of emails a day, many of them astoundingly trivial and irritating, but…that’s the job, and I can do it, or I can join the navy.

You’re leaving soon; either move your exit date up or learn some deep-breathing exercises, but either way, adjust the attitude. This is how your boss does things, which you’ve known for two years, so it’s a bit late to act martyred by it.

Share!
Pin Share


Tags:        

Comments are closed.